Hello dear
Welcome To The Cull House
In a quaint harbor setting at the Cull House, indulge in fresh seafood delights paired with fantastic drinks. The lobster bisque and lobster rolls receive high praise, while the broiled captains platter is a standout choice. Despite some minor changes under new ownership like smaller side portions and cheaper utensils, the overall dining experience remains exceptional. Enjoy a casual atmosphere with friendly service, perfect for a local seafood outing or special occasions. Don't miss out on the gluten-free options and mocktail menu, making this a versatile dining destination for all.
About
The Cull House
Welcome to The Cull House, a seafood and beer bar located in Sayville, NY. This cozy spot offers a variety of amenities such as reservations, delivery, takeout, and even live music. With a focus on seafood, The Cull House provides a wide range of appetizers, soups, salads, and specials like the delicious Flounder Francaise.
Customers have raved about the fantastic drinks, lobster rolls, and lobster bisque. The service is friendly and attentive, making you feel like a regular. The ambiance invokes a harbor feel, with views of the boat docks adding to the dining experience.
One patron mentioned that The Cull House has been a favorite for over 28 years, praising the food quality and atmosphere. While some mentioned concerns about the size of sides and utensil choices, overall, The Cull House remains a go-to spot for tasty and simple seafood dishes.
Whether you're in the mood for steamers, lobster rolls, or seafood gumbo, The Cull House has something for everyone. With options for vegetarians and gluten-free menu items, it's a place where everyone can enjoy a satisfying meal.
Next time you're in the area, make sure to stop by The Cull House for a delightful dining experience filled with fresh seafood and warm hospitality.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ What a great spot! Fantastic drinks and one of the best lobster rolls. Service treated like you were a regular so friendly and perceptive of our needs. Ambiance is warm and gives you the feeling that you are on a harbor, which you are. View of the boat docks which make for a nice stroll after dinner. ”
“ This IS the best simple seafood around. The lobster bisque is to die for!!! The lobster roll delicious! . I had the broiled captains platter perfect! The service is fantastic! Ambiance is a low key your local place to go. The only thing I didn't like ( was plastic silverware and throw away soup bowl ). But I hate it personal preference.... But sooo good highly recommend! ”
“ We have been going to the Cull House for 28 years. John the previous owner was great. We love the location, atmosphere and of course the food. Eating sometimes on carboard plates and plastic utensils never bothered us because the food was so good, and we understood why. When we went back for the first time under the new ownership, we were not disappointed. The place looks great and most important the food is still great. I do have to ping them on two negatives if I'm being honest. They have shrunk the sizes of the sides. The potato salad and coleslaw got smaller. The prices didn't shrink though. Its Potato Salad and Coleslaw!!!??? Also, they went to cheaper flimsyer utensils!!! John always had a higher end plastic that held up and astatically looked pretty good. Come on guys, really??? Don't cheap out on stuff like that, not when it's a nice sit-down restaurant that and not when it's gotten pricey. I would have given 5 Stars if not for those two negatives. PS: Bring back the bag of crackers at the table!!!!:) ”
“ I came with my fiancé looking for steamers. We ended up ordering two orders of steamers, the oysters rockerfeller, and the seafood gumbo. Steamers were good which is why we ended up ordering another one. Everything else was pretty mediocre. VERY expensive overall. My fiancé says he'd rate the place 3.5 stars. I rated it a 4 cause I was mostly just looking for steamers and those stood out. Will come back again but legit only will be ordering steamers. ”
“ Very nice Mother's Day lunch. They had a gluten free bun for the lobster roll. Very nice portion of lobster. I like that they have a mocktail menu. I was unable to have fries due to cross contamination. I was happy to be able to substitute a baked potatoes. Mom said the fries were great! ”
“ Recommended! Had a wonderful experience here recently. We will return and we highly recommend Cull House. Great food, super super service, Casual atmosphere, near Fire Island Ferries in Sayville. Server was a 10+++, and the manager came to each table to converse with customers! A big plus! Really shows buy-in and dedication to customers and product! For apps we had some delicious Long island Steamers. Tender and flavorful, served with drawn butter and clam broth in an iron skillet. Really good! We also had a nice wedge salad, a crisp and snappy favorite of ours. Cull House got this relatively easy salad right. (Sometimes other restsursnt miss on the easy stuff) For mains we had a lobster roll and the broiled fisherman's platter. The lobster roll was "cold style" with sweet snd flavorful lobster meat in light mayo with a small trace of celery. Nicely done. The roll was a garlic buttered brioche style hot dog bun. An interesting variation to the traditional plain white bread hot dog bun. The lobster roll came with 2 sides. We choose coleslaw and coconut white rice. Both sides were nice and the coconut rice was especially flavorful. We also has a broiled fisherman's platter. The platter had a generous portion of bay scallops, shrimp, flounder, a baked clam and a crab cake, really good! it also came with our choice of two sides. We choose coleslaw and steamed broccoli which had a delicious bonus chipotle mayo! Really good! After we finished our meal, Our server brought us over a desert menu with a really nice selection of house made deserts snd desert drinks. Note: dont skip the deserts! Totally amazing! Super good! We had chocolate espresso bars and crem brûlée, both exceptional. So good, Id maybe even come here just for desert! Also consider Cull House for catering! They have a lobster bake shore dinner that i would consider for a party or event. Highly recommend, reasonably priced and casual. ”
